Saturday, August 20, 2022

Michele and Hayward: Word Portraits of Queens Mary and Elizabeth.

For all that we are pleased to have portraits of Queens Mary and Elizabeth, they lack perspective that can only be found in verbal description. Not only perspective as to who they were but how others perceived them under various circumstances.

We think of Mary, perhaps, as physically plain, frumpy in her presentation, and her few portraits seem to support the view. But when she became a Queen, subject of the hopes of many, we find another recognizable portrait. Here she is described, circa 1557, by the Venetian ambassador Giovanni Michele.

She is of low stature, but has no deformity in any part of her person. She is thin and delicate, and altogether unlike her father, who was tall and strongly made, or her mother, who, although not tall, was stout. Her features are well formed, and, as her portraits prove, was considered, when younger, not merely good-looking but more than moderately pretty. At present, with the exception of some wrinkles, caused more by sorrow than by years, which make her appear older than in fact she is, her looks are of a grave and sedate cast. Her eyes are so piercing as to command not only respect but awe from those on whom she casts them, yet she is very near sighted, being unable to read, or do anything else, without placing her eyes quite close to the object. Her voice is deep-toned, and rather masculine, so that when she speaks she is heard some distance off. In conclusion, she is a well-looking lady, nor, putting out of the question her rank as Queen, should she ever be spoken ill of for want of sufficient beauty.[1]

It seems fair to say that this is not the general impression that one receives from her portraits and Protestant biographers. The eye of a Catholic ambassador sees the world quite differently than a contemporary fan of Tudor history. Perhaps more  honestly.

As much as the description might seem unexpectedly complimentary, the description of Queen Elizabeth I in Hayward’s Chronicles makes Mary’s look diplomatic.  

Now, if ever any persone had eyther the gift or the stile to winne the hearts of people, it was this Queene; and if ever she did expresse the same, it was at that present, in coupling mildnesse with majesty as she did, and in stately stouping to the meanest sort. All her facultyes were in motione, and every motione seemed a well guided actione; her eye was set upon one, her eare listened to another, her judgement ranne uppon a third, to a fourth she addressed her speech; her spiritt seemed to be every-where, and yet so [entire] in her selfe, as it seemed to bee noe where else. Some she pityed, some she commended, some she thanked, at others she pleasantly and wittily [jested], contemning noe person, neglecting noe office; and distributing her smiles, lookes, and graces, soe artificially, that thereupon the people againe redoubled the testimonyes of their joyes; and afterwards, raising every thing to the highest straine, filled the eares of all men with immoderate extolling their Prince.[2]

John Hayward was born around the year of Elizabeth’s ascension to the throne. While this is not, then, a first person memory, he had been collecting historical recollections throughout his adult life. Surely, he depended upon sources and his own observations from later in the Queen’s long reign.

About Elizabeth’s physical appearance upon becoming Queen he goes on at even greater length.

She was a Lady, upon whom nature had bestowed, and well placed, many of her fayrest favores; of stature meane, slender, streight, and amiably composed; of such state in her carriage, as every motione of her seemed to beare majesty: her haire was inclined to pale yellow, her foreheade large and faire, a [seeming seat] for princely grace; her eyes lively and sweete, but short-sighted; her nose somewhat rising in the middest; the whole compasse of her countenance somewhat long, but yet of admirable beauty, not so much in that which is tearmed the flower of youth, as in a most delightfull compositione of majesty and modesty in equall mixture. But without good qualityes of mynde, the gifts of nature are like paynted floweres, without eyther vertue or sappe; yea, sometimes they grow horrid and loathsome. Now her vertues were such as might suffice to make an Aethiopian beautifull, which, the more a man knowes and understands, the more he shall admire and love. In life, she was most innocent; in desires, moderate; in purpose, just; of spirit, above credit and almost capacity of her sexe; of divine witt, as well for depth of judgment, as for quicke conceite and speedy expeditione; of eloquence, as sweete in the utterance, soe ready and easie to come to the utterance: of wonderfull knowledge both in learning and affayres; skilfull not only in the Latine and Greeke, but [also] in divers other [foreign] languages: none knew better the hardest art of all others, that is, of commanding men, nor could more use themselves to those cares without which the [royal] dignity could not be supported. She was [religious], magnanimous, mercifull and just; respective of the honour of others, and exceeding tender in the touch of her owne. She was lovely and loving, the two principall bands of duty and obedience. She was very ripe and measured in [counsel] and experience, as well not to lett goe occasiones, as not to take them when they were greene. She maintained Justice at home, and Armes abroad, with great wisdome and authority in eyther place. Her majesty seemed to all to shine though courtesy: but as she was not easy to receive any to especiall grace, so was she most constant to those whom she received; and of great judgment to know to what point of greatnesse men were fit to bee advanced. She was rather liberall than magnificent, making good [choice] of the [receivers]; and for this cause was thought weake by some against the desire of money. But it is certaine that beside the want of treasure which she found, her continuall affayres in Scottland, France, the Low Countries, and in  Ireland, did occasione greate provisione of money, which could not bee better supplyed, than by cutting off eyther excessive or unnecessary expence at home. 

Excellent Queene! what doe my words but wrong thy worth? what doe I but guild gold? what but shew the sunne with a candle, in attempting to prayse thee, whose honor doth flye over the whole world upon the two wings of Magnanimity and Justice, whose perfection shall much dimme the lustre of all other that shall be of thy sexe?[3]

Apart from a bias or two, mild for their time, this is an eloquent description of which few writers are capable and even monarchs rarely provoke. Especially a monarch who imprisoned the writer in The Tower at the end of their reign as she did John Hayward.

 



[1] Madden, Frederick. Privy Purse Expenses of the Princess Mary (1831). xlv-xlvi.

[2] Bruce, John. Annals Of The First Four Years Of The Reign Of Queen Elizabeth, By Sir John Hayward, Knt. D.C.L. (1840). 6-7.

[3] Ibid. 7-8.


Also at Virtual Grub Street:


  • Queen Elizabeth I Truly Loved a Good Play. August 6, 2022. “The Queen, for her part, was surely looking forward to an entertaining evening watching a play.”
  • The Tudor Version of International First-Class Mail. June 11, 2022. “…they had established a system that was centuries old and the fastest available however much letters often took weeks or even months to reach their destinations.”
  • Livin’ Real at Windsor Castle with Queen Elizabeth. June 4, 2022. “Being fans of the Queen and the times, we watch television miniseries and movies draped with intrigue, lust and tapestries.”
  • Queen Elizabeth’s Jealousy could be frightening to mere mortals. February 6, 2022. “I adventured to say, as far as discretion did go, in defence of our friende; and did urge muche in behalfe of youthe and enticinge love,…”
  • To Where Did Queen Elizabeth I Disappear in August 1564? July 18, 2021. “Leicestershire was in the opposite direction from London. Nichols could discover no more.”
  • Check out the English Renaissance Article Index for many more articles and reviews about this fascinating time and about the Shakespeare Authorship Question.
  • Check out the Queen Elizabeth I Biography Page for many other articles.

  • No comments: