Saturday, April 09, 2022

Henry VIII and Charles V Begin Negotiations for Princess Mary to Marry.

The Infante Don Luis and Lady Mary 
Also in this series: 

 

 

As was mentioned in the earlier post — The Plans to Abduct the Princess Mary — Emperor Charles V and his ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, were actively plotting, in 1536, to spirit Henry VIII’s daughter, Lady Mary, away from England. Henry may have had a sense that Catholic plots of that sort might be expected, Mary representing their hopes that the kingdom would return to the old religion. Nevertheless, it is astonishing that the Holy Roman Emperor himself could be the leader of a plot to kidnap a daughter of royal family.

The strategy of regularly moving Mary’s household on short notice did, indeed, foil their plans. Charles fell back to a plan-B of getting her out of the country by marrying her off to his brother-in-law, Don Luiz, second son to the King of Portugal.

It is almost as astonishing to find that the Emperor and ambassador were still watching for their opportunity some two and a half years later. In the person of a special ambassador, Don Diego de Mendoza, the Emperor had put forward marriage candidates for both Mary and for Henry himself in 1538. For Mary, Don Luiz was still the choice. For Henry, the Emperor offered Christina, the 17 year old dowager Duchess of Milan.

Mendoza was quickly replaced as Charles’ representative in the negotiations by Mary, the dowager Queen of Hungary, and governor of the Netherlands. Mary was also the governess of the orphaned Dorothea and Christina of Denmark. Perhaps, equally important, the dowager was a close cousin of the deceased Katherine of Aragon.

The French King Francis I was informed forthwith that Charles had promised Henry VIII the Duchy of Milan as part of Mary’s wedding settlement. Francis had already been promised Milan by the Emperor, and, for all he expressed confidence that their agreement would stand, his diplomats were instructed to do all that was possible to prevent matters going forward.

How Henry came to understand that he was offered Milan is not clear. Thus matters stood when Chapuys wrote the Emperor on August 31, 1538.

This seemed to us a fair opportunity to ask her, as we did, then and there, whether, in case of a favourable opportunity presenting itself, she would have courage enough to leave England by stealth. To this question of ours, the Princess, from modesty, as we presume, did at first show some reluctance to reply. Then she said that she could not say yes or no, for things might arrive at such a pitch, and the occasion for her departure from this country might become so propitious and favourable, that she would have no scruple or difficulty at all in leaving anyhow. She would let me (Chapuys) know her intentions on that score; for it might happen after all that the King, her father, might hereafter show greater consideration for her, or cause her to be more respected and better treated than she had-been until now, in which case she would much prefer remaining in England, and conforming herself entirely to her father’s commands and wishes, obeying him implicitly, and so forth, though still acting by my (Chapuys), advice. Such was the Princess’ language in the two long conferences we held with her. In short, she begged us to present Your Majesty her most humble commendations until she herself did so by letter.[1]

The option of kidnapping Mary was still very much in the mix. Mary felt her position in the English Court might be improved, she having become marriage bait. But she did not necessarily know that Henry stood to be greatly disappointed not to receive the highly lucrative Duchy of Milan.

At some point, however, Mary’s living conditions, loosened after Anne Boleyn’s miscarriage of early 1536, had been tightened again. When Don Hurtado writes the Emperor, on September 14, she is ill.

The Princess (Mary) when I last saw her was in good health, but for the last few days (I hear) she has been rather delicate. I fancy the cause to be the confinement (estrechez) in which she lives, for nowadays she is kept much closer and more poorly than before. Her Highness’ personal commendations I reserve for next occasion when I am in Your Imperial Majesty’s presence.[2]

Hurtado feels that her living conditions are to blame. Any hopes she might have had of better treatment under the new circumstances had yet to be realized. In fact, quite the opposite.

At the same time, the dowager Duchess of Hungary was seeking instructions from Charles. There were many practical matters to be settled.

You may also tell the King that in order to forward those negociations, and proceed more steadily in the matter, so as to bring the whole affair to a conclusion as soon as possible; knowing, moreover, that he has already been acquainted by you with the conditions of both marriages—that of the Infante of Portugal, Dom Luys, and that of the dowager duchess of Milan, our niece—I beg him to be pleased to state to you in writing what property and rank (avancement?) he intends giving to his daughter, the Princess; what dower he purposes for the Duchess, and what property is to be inherited by the sons and descendants of the said marriages, his own and the Princess’. That being done, and perfectly understood on both sides, so as to make things quite clear, the King may send his ambassadors when he likes.[3]

Negotiations were about to get underway in earnest.



[1] Spanish Letters. VI.i.26. London, 31 August 1538,

[2] Spanish Letters. VI.i.43. From Breda, 14 September 1538.

[3] Spanish Letters. VI.i.47-8. 16 September 1538. Draft copy.


Also at Virtual Grub Street:


  • Anne Boleyn’s Coming Out at the English Court. February 13, 2022. “The Knight in the beginninge cominge to beholde the sudden apearance of this new bewtie came to beholden and surprized somewhat with the sight therof, after much more with her wittie and graceful speech…”
  • King Henry VII’s Thank You Note to  Pope Innocent VIII. January 9, 2021. “In the etiquette of power even kings were wise to send thank you notes.”
  • Making Mincemeat Out of It: Medieval and Tudor Mincemeat Pies. November 1, 2021. “I think it’s fair to say that anyone attempting to find medieval or Tudor recipes for mincemeat has failed.”
  • To Where Did Queen Elizabeth I Disappear in August 1564? July 18, 2021. “Leicestershire was in the opposite direction from London. Nichols could discover no more.”
  • Check out the English Renaissance Article Index for many more articles and reviews about this fascinating time and about the Shakespeare Authorship Question.
  • Check out the Queen Elizabeth I Biography Page for many other articles.

  • No comments: