Sunday, January 30, 2022

Gossip as History: Figure Flingers, Poisoners and Shrovetide Plays.


Even the finest annals and chronicles of Tudor times — such as those of John Stowe and John Strype — could descend to gossip without warning. Perhaps it is part of the charm of  them.

Even the well-educated Tudor author lived in a world shot through with active agents of the devil seeking to do evil at every level of society. Even a monarch or the doctor of a monarch went about their activities in the grip of these ideas. A great deal, then, has to be taken with a pinch of salt.

Was that a cramp? Or was it a sorcerer kneading a figure of you over which he or she had cast a spell? Or was it the sign of a slow poison?  Was the Queen’s agonizing toothache the effect of sugar or that figure being kneaded again, this time pushing a decayed tooth into its head?

Here Stowe tells the story of Simon Pembroke as gospel truth:

The seventeenth day of Januarie, [1578,] Simon Pembrooke, dwelling in Southwarke, being a figure flinger [astrologer], and vehemently suspected to be a conjurer, by commandment of the ordinarie Judge of those parts, appeared in the parish Church of Saint Saviour, at a court holden there, which Simon being busied in entertaining a Proctor, and having money in his hand, leaned his head upon a pewe, wherein the Proctor stood: which after he had done a certaine space, the proctor began to lift up his head, to see what he ayled, and found him departing out of life, and straitway the said Simon fell downe ratling a little in the throat, and never spake a word after: this was done even as the Judge came into the church, who said it was just judgement of God towards those that used sorcerie, and a great example to admonish other to feare the justice of God. After his clothes being opened, there were found about him five divelish Bookes of conjuration and most abominable pratices, with a picture of tinne of a man having three dice in his hand, with this writing, Chaunce Dice fortunately, and diverse papers of such like matters, as he had dealt in for men, such as are mentioned in Leviticus the twentieth Chapter and the first verse: If any soule turne himselfe after such worke with spirits, and after soothsayers, go a whooring after them (saith the Lord,) I will put my face against that soule, and will cut him off from among my people.[1]

While the judge in this tale seems to have some command over the dark powers, Queen Elizabeth had to rely on spies and informers according to Strype’s account. Even the Lord Great Treasurer Burghley stands in mortal danger.

Certain wickedly disposed persons this year [1578] practised magic against her majesty queen Elizabeth, to take away her life.... [T]hree waxen images were framed; whereof one was of the queen, and the two other of two persons nearest her, (perhaps the lord treasurer Burghley, and the lord high steward, the earl of Leicester,) which were found in the house of a priest near Islington, (who was a magician, and so reputed,) in order to take away their lives.

For all they were caught, the powers of darkness may have had a degree of success.

Whether it were the effect of this magic, or proceeded from some natural cause, but the queen was in some part of this year under excessive anguish by pains of her teeth; insomuch that she took no rest for divers nights, and endured very great torment night and day. There was now in England an outlandish physician, called Fenot, that happened to be then at court. To whom some lords of the council applied themselves; requiring and commanding him to give his advice in this extremity for the queen's ease. In obedience whereunto that learned physician wrote a long letter in Latin unto them, dated the calends of December. Wherein first, he shewed, “how dangerous a thing it was for him to give his judgment,…”. But at length he gives his advice to use several things. But, after all, if they proved ineffectual, and the tooth was hollow and decayed, then he advised that it might be drawn out.

Perhaps as an attempt to overpower the forces against the Queen, her beloved Leicester brings in a new doctor to instruct her attendants.

There was now belonging to the court another physician of fame, that was an Italian, named Dr. Julio Borgarucei, of whom mention hath been made elsewhere; a great favourite of the earl of Leicester, (and of whom stories go, that he made great use of for feats of poisoning.) This Italian doctor had some persons (whether the queen's wards or henchmen, I know not) committed to his charge, for instructing them in learning and in the language.

But he is reputed to be Leicester’s private poisoner. If this were more than rumor among chroniclers would she possibly have allowed it? Oh well, it doesn’t seem to have overwhelmed the Queen’s pleasure in Shrovetide plays.

At Shrovetide, according as it seemed customary at that season, were shows presented at court before her majesty at night. The chiefest was a device presented by the persons of the earl of Oxford, the earl of Surrey, the lords Thomas Hayworth [Howard] and Windsour. But the device (as the lord Talbot wrote to the earl his father) was prettier than it had hap to be performed. [The young noblemen, it seems, did not so well acquit their parts.] But the best of it, added that lord, and I think the best liked, was two rich jewels, which were presented to her majesty by the two earls.[2]

She generally expressed her pleasure at these entertainments. Sometimes with lusty applause, sometimes even with gifts. And why not? Virtually every moment of a Tudor life was itself a gift which might be savagely crimped or rescinded at any moment.

 



[1] Stowe, John. Annals of England (1603), 1159.

[2] Strype, John. Annals of the Reformation… (1725, 1824) II.ii. 206-7, 208-9.


Also at Virtual Grub Street:


  • White Wands, 1574 Plague Policy and the Context of Plague Times. December 30, 2021. “FOR auoyding of the increase and spreading of the infection of the plague wythin this Citie, so much as by good polycie it Iyeth in us to doe”.
  • The Funeral of Queen Mary I. December 13 & 14, 1558. November 30, 2021. “She was buried with a pomp suitable to her princely quality, by special order of the Queen her sister, and her Council”.
  • To Where Did Queen Elizabeth I Disappear in August 1564? July 18, 2021. “Leicestershire was in the opposite direction from London. Nichols could discover no more.”
  • Lady Southwell on the Final Days of Queen Elizabeth I.  March 24, 2019.  “her majesty told [Lady Scrope] (commanding her to conceal the same ) that she saw, one night, in her bed, her body exceeding lean, and fearful in a light of fire.”
  • Check out the English Renaissance Article Index for many more articles and reviews about this fascinating time and about the Shakespeare Authorship Question.
  • Check out the Queen Elizabeth I Biography Page for many other articles.
  • No comments: